This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Subscribe
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • Home
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Edition
    • Archives
    • Radiant & Hydronics Report
    • Green Plumbing & Heating
    • Fire Protection & Design Special Section
    • NSF Design Special Section
    • Radiant Comfort Guide
    • PVF Outlook
    • Ad Index
  • Market Sectors
    • Green Plumbing
    • Green Mechanical Systems
    • Codes
    • Fire Protection
    • Radiant/Hydronics
    • Solar Thermal/Geothermal
    • Bath & Kitchen
    • Water Treatment
    • Technology
  • eNewsletter
    • Supply House Times e-news
    • pme eNewsletter Archives
    • Radiant & Hydronics eNews Archives
    • Bath & Kitchen Pro eNews Archives
    • Western Plumbing News Archives
    • Subscribe to Plumbing Group eNewsletters
  • Columnists
    • Julius Ballanco on Codes
    • Ed McMenamin: Editor's Note
    • John Siegenthaler: Renewable Heating Design
    • Dan Holohan: Heating Help
    • Ray Wohlfarth: The Boiler Room
    • Jacqueline Wilmot: Fire Protection
    • Blog
  • Multimedia
    • pme Network Videos
    • eBook
    • Photo Gallery
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Mobile App
    • Interactive Spotlights
  • Web Exclusives
  • Products
  • More
    • B.I.G. Book
    • History of Plumbing
    • Rep Locator
    • Industry Calendar
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Classified Ads
    • Market Research
    • Bookstore
    • Continuing Education
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Submission Guidelines
  • Advertise
Home » Julius Ballanco: Status quo for ASME’s sponsorship of A112 standards
Julius Ballanco on CodesPlumbing, Mechanical & Fire CodesColumnists

Julius Ballanco: Status quo for ASME’s sponsorship of A112 standards

Status quo for ASME’s sponsorship of A112 standards
May 22, 2018
Julius Ballanco P.E., CPD
KEYWORDS ICC / International Mechanical Code / international plumbing code / plumbing codes / water heater
Reprints
No Comments

In the middle of the ICC code hearings in Columbus, Ohio, ASME sent a memorandum to the ASME A112 Committee announcing ICC and CSA would not be taking over the A112 standards. ASME has decided to continue to sponsor the standards.

The timing of the announcement is interesting since many of the plumbing codes and standards professionals were present for the ICC plumbing hearings. There was surprise and relief with the decision. Many in the profession were concerned with ICC and CSA taking control. After years of ASME promulgating the standards, the concern was whether ICC and CSA would continue with as smooth a change process as ASME. There was relief there wouldn’t be any change in the process. The fear of the switch in promulgators was of the unknown.

At the ICC plumbing hearing there were nine new members to the Plumbing Code Committee, with only five returning members. Chairman Charlie Gerber, from Henrico County, Virginia, had his hands full. However, he did an excellent job keeping everyone on point. It also was refreshing to see Jim Finley, P.E., appointed as vice chair.

 

Odd comments

Like most of the plumbing code hearings, there were some bizarre statements made during testimony. During discussion of a change to limit the annual quantity of water to trap-seal primary valves, there was opposing testimony that included flushing of fire hydrants. What that had to do with limiting the water to prevent the loss of a trap seal was beyond most of the people in the audience. That change, which would have restricted water use to 30 gal. per year for a water-supplied trap-primer valve, was recommended for denial.

Similar water-conservation measures also were denied. One change would have lowered the urinal flush rate to 0.5 gpf. Another would have restricted the showerhead flow rate to being associated with a single valve. So when multiple showerheads are installed, the total flow rate would be 2.5 gpm for all showerheads combined.

Having chaired one of the ASSE working groups on water heaters, I made a commitment to propose a series of changes on the three new water-heater standards, ASSE 1082, 1084 and 1085. ASSE 1082 is a water heater rated for equivalency to an ASSE 1017 thermostatic mixing valve. ASSE 1084 is similar to a 1070 valve and ASSE 1085 is similar to a 1071 valve for emergency fixtures.

ICC has a policy requiring drafts of the standard to be submitted for review. Since the draft of ASSE 1084 was not submitted within the required time limit, a modification to delete ASSE 1084 had to be proposed for each code change.

With the valve standards listed in numerous sections, there were many changes proposed regarding the new ASSE water-heater standards. When similar changes are submitted, you anticipate similar results. That did not occur.

There was testimony for and against each of the changes. The opposition often centered on the fact the standards have not been published. However, ICC allows the initial acceptance of a draft. The standard is required to be finalized by the annual meeting in the fall. Because the standards have not yet been published, ASSE testified in opposition to its own standards. This was rather strange. Normally a standards organization supports its changes even when they are submitted as a draft.

Some of the water-heater standard changes were recommended for approval with the modification to delete ASSE 1084, while other similar changes were recommended for denial. The most important standard in the group, the water heaters for emergency fixtures, was recommended for approval. This change will greatly assist the plumbing engineering community by allowing water heaters to be located at the point where the emergency fixtures are installed.

 

Keeping it light

There always are lighthearted moments that appear very tense while listening to testimony. This often occurs when one subject matter is heard by a committee not used to that topic. Water-closet and urinal partitions were addressed by the Fire Safety Committee for the Building Code. The concern was plastic partitions. In fire experts’ minds, water-closet and urinal partitions made of plastic will burn and kill people in a fire. Plumbing experts know that plastic partitions are safe, with many wonderful qualities regarding sanitation.

I participated in the testimony, although I knew speaking to fire people meant that any time they heard the word “fire,” they had to do something. While there are zero fire statistics regarding plastic water-closet and toilet partitions, it didn’t seem to matter. All that mattered is that under certain fire tests the partitions burn. It was one of those “duh” moments. The Fire Safety Committee voted to continue requiring fire tests that virtually prohibit plastic water-closet and toilet partitions.

For the remainder of the week, many commented on the partitions code changes. Some of the comments were, we allow showers that can’t pass the fire test, yet prohibit partitions. We allow baby-changing stations with the same plastic as partitions (which can’t pass the fire test), but we ban partitions. No one said the committee decisions always make sense.

A similar lighthearted moment occurred when the Plumbing Code Committee had to deal with a change involving screening of public toilet rooms. This is a subject normally addressed by architects, but it appeared before the Plumbing Committee. There were discussions of being able to view someone in a mirror as the toilet room door is opened.

The Plumbing Code Committee voted to approve the change requiring screening and privacy for commercial toilet rooms. This followed all the approvals of the single-occupant toilet room requirements to address the requests of the transgender community.

If there was one central theme for plumbing, it had to be Legionnaires’ disease. ASHRAE submitted a code change to require all water-distribution systems to be designed in accordance with ASHRAE 188, the ASHRAE risk-management standard.

There was extensive testimony both for and against ASHRAE 188. The support was obvious, claiming the standard addresses a necessary issue in the plumbing engineering community. The opposition centered around the change being all encompassing, applying to all buildings. The other issue was the standard is a risk assessment, not a design standard. The committee recommended denial of the code change.

The results of all the code changes can be found at www.cpdACCESS.com.

Subscribe to PM Engineer

Recent Articles by Julius Ballanco

Julius Ballanco: How hot is too hot?

Julius Ballanco: Lead in drinking water continues to be a hot topic for NSF

Julius Ballanco: Where has the honor in code-change debate gone?

Julius Ballanco: The demise of ASSE 1070

Julius Ballanco: Transgender bathrooms will be a central topic at ICC Final Action hearings

Ballancojuliusvwhite_200

Julius Ballanco, P.E., CPD, F-ASPE, is president of J.B. Engineering and Code Consulting, P.C. in Munster, Ind. He can be reached at by email at jbengineer@aol.com.

Related Articles

Julius Ballanco: Lead in drinking water continues to be a hot topic for NSF

Julius Ballanco: The demise of ASSE 1070

ICC is fixing serious problems

That's a wrap

Related Events

ICC, PMI Webinar: Changes to the 2015 IPC

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

Dave Yates, owner, York Pennsylvania-based F. W. Behler

Plumbing industry takes harder look at legionella threat

Julius Ballanco

Julius Ballanco: How hot is too hot?

Uponor.jpg

Uponor wins project of the year award for Hutchinson facility

Moen-Nebia-combined.jpg

Moen partners with Nebia to develop shower innovations

pme's Top 20 Products of 2017

pme's Top 20 Products of 2018

PME-Top20Products360


Mechanical Engineer of the Year 2017 360

Events

July 24, 2018

Increase Word of Mouth for Your Business with Online Reviews

ON DEMAND: Most people will recognize that word of mouth is your best form of marketing. Whether they’re recommending your store to their close circle or sharing their feelings on an online review site, what they say can go a long way toward convincing potential customers to do business with you. So what can you to harness the voice of your customers and make sure it is reaching the right people at the right time?

February 19, 2019

KBIS 2019

This year’s show will be held from February 19-21, 2019.

View All Submit An Event

Products

Valve Handbook

Valve Handbook

Revised to include details on the latest technologies, Valve Handbook, Third Edition, discusses design, performance, selection, operation, and application.

See More Products

PME Rep Locator


pme How-To Directory Videos

PM Engineer Magazine

pme february cover 2019

2019 February

The February 2019 issue of PM Engineer focuses on water safety, specifically the threat of legionella and how engineers can reduce risk by referencing ASHRAE Standard 188. Also in the magazine, Julius Ballanco’s analysis of potentially dangerous proposed changes to Illinois’ plumbing code, a look at new data-collecting sensor faucets and John Siegenthaler, P.E., tells us about different configurations for thermal storage tanks. The February edition also features debut columns by new contributors Ethan Grossman, P.E., on unit conversions, Rocco Luisi on business advice and Christoph Lohr, P.E., on recruiting and retaining talent.

View More Subscribe
  • Resources
    • List Rental
    • Reprints
    • eNewsletters
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Editorial Submissions
  • Want More?
    • Subscribe
    • Industry Links
    • Connect
    • Survey And Sample
  • Plumbing Group
    • Plumbing & Mechanical
    • Reeves Journal
    • Supply House Times

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing